What is envy?
Envy is resentment at someone else’s good fortune, the moment “I wanted that part too” starts to feel like “she didn’t deserve it.”
When a friend gets the part you wanted
You and a friend audition for the same part. She gets it. On the way home, you keep replaying the moment her name was called. The same piece of news can bring up several feelings.
- Disappointment. You had pictured yourself onstage. Losing that chance hurts, and you can still be glad your friend gets to perform.
- Envy. You start picking apart her audition. It feels easier to explain why she didn’t deserve the part than to admit how much you wanted it.
- Jealousy. Later, she spends evenings rehearsing with a new castmate. This time you worry that you might lose your place in her life.
In their study of how people experience these emotions, Parrott and Smith found that envy involved longing and resentment, while jealousy often involved fear of loss. Read the original study.
Catholic teaching describes envy as sorrow over another person’s good fortune coupled with an excessive desire to have what they possess. The quiz asks about two responses you can recall. Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraph 2539.
How two answers can give an envy score of 75%
| Statement | Choice | Points |
|---|---|---|
| Question 6When a colleague gets an opportunity I wanted, I look for a reason they did not earn it. | Often | 3/4 |
| Question 13I leave a friend’s good news unanswered because my own plans are going badly. | Often | 3/4 |
| Example total | 3 + 3 | 6/8 75% |
Both answers earn three points in this example. On a retake, four points on one statement and two on the other would produce the same total.
Paired with Kindness Compare the scores
What could I say to my friend?
Pick one thing you remember from their preparation. “I remember how long you worked on that scene. When does rehearsal start?” gives them room to enjoy the part, even while you are still disappointed.
Envy FAQ
Can I question an unfair decision without being envious?
Yes. If the casting call promised everyone a callback and some people never got one, you have a specific concern to raise with the director. A question about how the decision was made is different from assuming the person who got the part lacked talent.
How can I score high in both envy and kindness?
The quizzes ask about different situations. You might resent a colleague’s promotion and still check in on a friend who has gone quiet. Look at the answers that contributed to each score before drawing a conclusion about either one.